Who gets to tell the hemophilia story?

I’ve noticed something strange over the years: Adults with hemophilia sometimes disappear from conversations that were built for them.

I first noticed it in support groups. The louder caregivers became, the quieter some people with hemophilia seemed to get. Some stopped participating altogether. Others drifted toward spaces led by people with hemophilia themselves. As the wife of someone with severe hemophilia B, it feels almost disloyal to admit that.

After all, I am one of the caregivers — however reluctantly I wear the title.

I know what it’s like to prepare infusion supplies before a situation turns urgent, to watch out for rogue bleeds and seizures and try to stay calm when they occur, and to wonder whether your husband is minimizing pain because he’s lived with it for so long that discomfort barely registers as noteworthy anymore. People don’t become vigilant for no reason. Love often teaches us to anticipate disaster before it arrives.

Recommended Reading

Nov. 4, 2024 Columns by Allyx Formalejo

The benefits of pride and dignity, for people with disabilities in particular

So this isn’t a criticism of caregivers. If anything, it’s an acknowledgment of how much they carry. Parents of newly diagnosed children are thrown into a world of treatment schedules, insurance approvals, and terrifying possibilities they never asked to learn about. Partners learn to recognize subtle changes in expression and energy. Family members become advocates, organizers, researchers, and safety nets.

But over time, I’ve started to wonder whether caregivers and people with hemophilia sometimes arrive in the same spaces looking for different things.

Caregivers often come looking for information, reassurance, and ways to prevent the worst from happening. People with hemophilia may come looking for something else entirely. They may want to talk to others who understand what it’s like to grow up with a body that requires consideration but not constant fear. They may want permission to imagine futures larger than their diagnosis, or to discuss work, relationships, parenthood, exercise, travel, and ordinary frustrations without every conversation circling back to risk management.

Neither need is wrong. But they aren’t always the same.

Protection and permission

I don’t claim to speak for my husband. In fact, one of the reasons our marriage works is because I refuse to. We happen to agree on many things about living well with chronic illness, but agreement isn’t ownership. His life, voice, and body are still his.

That philosophy sounds admirable in theory. In practice, it’s much harder. Would I feel differently if his condition had been less stable? If I were the parent of a newly diagnosed toddler, would I become one of the loud caregivers?

Does our perspective come with a degree of naivete? We’re still relatively young, after all. Will more years of experience strengthen these beliefs, or dilute them? Will we become even more committed to making room for autonomy, or more cautious in the face of everything that can go wrong? I don’t know.

What I do know is that I understand why caregivers become loud. When you’ve witnessed someone’s pain up close, vigilance can feel like the purest expression of devotion. You don’t want the person you love to suffer because of something you failed to prevent.

At the same time, I’ve known caregivers who hold that fear more lightly. People who trust deeply, encourage independence, and don’t see risk as something that must always dominate the conversation. I hope to be one of them.

Maybe that’s why I’ve started to wonder whether support communities sometimes confuse being cared for with being spoken for.

Making room

Maybe the tension isn’t really between caregivers and people with hemophilia. Maybe it’s between two equally loving desires: the desire to keep someone safe and the desire to let them live.

Caregivers know what could happen, and many cannot bear the thought of losing the people they love. People with hemophilia know what could happen, too. They live with that knowledge every day, yet still want the freedom to decide what kind of life is worth having. Both perspectives emerge from love. They’re simply answering different questions.

I’ve stopped wondering which group is right. Instead, I’ve started wondering what our communities might look like if we became more intentional about honoring each other’s truths.

What would happen if caregivers had places to lay down their fear without feeling guilty for it? If people with hemophilia had spaces to imagine lives larger than their diagnoses? More importantly, could we learn to listen to one another without assuming we’re telling the same story?

I don’t have the answer.

But I suspect one of the greatest gifts we can give the people we love is remembering that they remain the experts in their own lives. Sometimes support means stepping in. Sometimes it means stepping back. Wisdom is learning the difference.

Note: Hemophilia News Today is strictly a news and information website about the disease. It does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. This content is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult your physician or another qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this website. The opinions expressed in this column are not those of Hemophilia News Today or its parent company, Bionews, and are intended to spark discussion about issues pertaining to hemophilia.